Senior’s admonition at workplace not criminal offence: SC

New Delhi, Feb 16: Senior’s admonition at the workplace does not amount to an “intentional insult” requiring criminal proceedings, the Supreme Court has held.

The top court said allowing criminal charges to be pressed against individuals in such cases may lead to disastrous consequences, crippling the entire disciplinary atmosphere required in the workplace.

A bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta said that mere abuse, discourtesy, rudeness or insolence do not amount to an intentional insult within the meaning of Section 504 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

Section 504 of the IPC deals with intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of peace.

The offence, punishable with jail term of up to two years, has now been replaced with Section 352 under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) effective from July 2024.

The top court’s judgement came while quashing a 2022 criminal case against the officiating director of the National Institute for Empowerment of Persons with Intellectual Disabilities, who was accused of insulting an assistant professor.

The complainant had alleged that the director scolded and reprimand her in front of other employees for submitting complaints against him to the higher authorities.

It was also alleged that the director failed to provide and maintain adequate PPE kits in the institute, which posed a great risk of spreading infectious diseases such as Covid-19.

The apex court said from the bare perusal of the chargesheet and documents relied therein, the allegations seem to be purely conjectural, and by no stretch of imagination they can be considered sufficient to constitute the ingredients of the offences under Sections 269 (negligent acts that could spread a dangerous disease) and 270 (malicious act of spreading a life-threatening disease) of the IPC.

“Therefore, in our opinion, senior’s admonition cannot be reasonably attributed to mean an ‘intentional insult with the intent to provoke’ within the means of Section 504, IPC, provided that the admonition relates to the matters incidental to the workplace covering discipline and the discharge of duties therein,” the bench said.

“It is a reasonable expectation on the part of a person who caters to the affairs at the helm that his juniors should attend to their professional duties with utmost sincerity and dedication,” the judgment, delivered on February 10, said. (PTI)

Hot this week

Pay hike of Assam ministers, MLAs likely as 3-member panel submits report

Full report likely by Oct 30 Guwahati Sept 25: There...

Meghalaya Biological Park Inaugurated After 25 Years: A New Chapter in Conservation and Education

Shillong, Nov 28: Though it took nearly 25 years...

Meghalaya man missing in Bangkok

Shillong, Jan 10: A 57-year-old Meghalaya resident, Mr. Treactchell...

ANSAM rejects Kuki’s separate administration demand, says bifurcation not acceptable

Guwahati, Sept 8: Rejecting the separate administration demand of...

Meghalaya’s historic fiber paves the way for eco-friendly products and sustainable livelihoods

By Roopak Goswami Shillong, Oct 25: From making earbuds to...

Netanyahu to head to Washington next Monday as Trump presses for ceasefire in Gaza

Washington, Jul 01: President Donald Trump will host Israel...

Tamang tells NHIDCL to construct double-lane highway to connect Sikkim with Bengal

Gangtok, Jul 01: Sikkim Chief Minister Prem Singh Tamang...

Woman murdered by ex-boyfriend at Mairang

Shillong, Jul 1: In another case of heinous crime,...

Suruchi and Saurabh win 10m pistol at national trials

Dehradun, June 30: Suruchi Inder Singh continued her remarkable...

Nikhat, Lovlina, Nitu enter finals of Elite Women’s Boxing Tournament

Hyderabad, June 30: World champions Nikhat Zareen, Lovlina Borgohain,...
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img